Evidence

What makes an electronic signature provable?

A signature image proves very little. What matters is the evidence around it: who acted, on which text, when, and whether anything changed afterwards.

By the AccordSeal team · Updated · 5 min read

When people picture an electronic signature, they picture the scribble at the bottom of the page. That image is the least important part. Anyone can paste a picture of a name into a PDF. What gives a signature weight is the record of how it got there.

The four questions

If a signature is ever disputed, the person assessing it will ask four things.

1. Who signed?

You need a link between the action and a person. That link is built from several signals rather than one: the signing link was sent to a specific email address, the signer entered a code that only they were given, and the device and network details were recorded at the time. The more independent signals there are, the harder it is to claim “that was not me”.

In AccordSeal, each signer receives a personal link. You can add an access code per signer and a one-time code sent by email or SMS. For higher-value agreements, an ID document check with liveness is available through a provider.

2. What did they sign?

The text must be fixed before anyone signs it. If the document could be edited after the first signature, nobody can say which version each person agreed to. A cryptographic fingerprint solves this: a SHA-256 hash changes completely if a single character changes.

AccordSeal freezes the PDF as an encrypted copy with a SHA-256 fingerprint at the moment the agreement is created, and document versions are immutable.

3. When did they sign?

A time written by the system that holds the document is only as trustworthy as that system. An independent timestamp authority, following the RFC 3161 standard, signs a statement that a particular hash existed at a particular time. That gives you a time that does not depend on the vendor's clock or honesty.

4. Has anything changed since?

This applies to two things: the document and the record of events. A digital seal on the PDF makes any later change to the file detectable. A hash-chained audit log does the same for the history: each event includes the hash of the one before it, so altering one entry breaks every link after it.

Evidence you can check without us

The strongest evidence is the kind a third party can verify on their own. That is why a completed AccordSeal agreement comes with three things:

  • A sealed final PDF with values and signatures stamped in place and the agreement ID on every page.
  • A certificate of completion listing recipients, timestamps, IP addresses, devices, consent and signatures, with a QR code and a verification code.
  • An evidence package: a ZIP containing the sealed PDFs, the original, the audit events with their hash inputs, the chain links, the timestamp tokens and a checksum file.

Anyone holding the document can also check it on the public verification portal, by code, by hash or by uploading the file. They do not need an account.

What this does not settle

Evidence shows what happened. It does not decide whether an electronic signature is acceptable for a particular kind of document under a particular law. Some documents must still be signed on paper or before a witness. That is a legal question, and the answer depends on where you are and what you are signing — ask your legal adviser.

It is also worth knowing what a platform's seal rests on. AccordSeal's seals are made with an AATL document-signing certificate, so PDF readers trust them automatically, and long-term validation levels are supported. Our security page describes the controls behind them.

Run your next agreement from draft to proof.

Start with the Free plan, or ask us to walk your team through AccordSeal with your own documents.